Blogs

Guest article by Malinda Anthony, Managing Director, Business Development, DeNovo Treasury

Why Security is the New Sales Priority

To understand why security must lead the sales conversation, one must look at the current fraud landscape. As adoption of instant payments continues to grow, so does exposure to Authorized Push Payment (APP) fraud. In these scenarios, the victim is manipulated into voluntarily authorizing a payment to a fraudster. Because the payment is authorized by the legitimate account holder, traditional technical blocks are often bypassed.

As real-time payment volumes continue to rise, the liability and reputational risk for financial institutions grow in tandem. For a commercial client, a single fraudulent instant payment can represent a catastrophic loss of liquidity. This is where the community bank or credit union advantage becomes clear. While a national bank may rely solely on automated algorithms to flag suspicious activity, a community financial institution combines technology with institutional knowledge of the client’s typical behavior.

When a community bank or credit union leads a treasury management pitch with a deep dive into fraud mitigation, they are addressing the primary unspoken fear of the modern CFO. They are moving the conversation from a commodity (the price of a wire or an instant payment) to a partnership (the protection of the client’s balance sheet).

The Community Financial Institution Superpower: Proximity and Institutional Knowledge

Large national banks often struggle with false positives. Their fraud models are so rigid that they frequently block legitimate business transactions, causing operational friction for the client. Conversely, when they fail to catch fraud, the client is often left navigating an automated phone tree to seek a resolution.

Community financial institutions possess a superpower that cannot be easily replicated by a global entity: proximity. This proximity is both physical and relational. In a treasury management context, this means the community bank or credit union knows that a specific manufacturing client typically pays their steel supplier on the 15^th of every month. If an instant payment request surfaces on the 30^th for a different amount to a new routing number, the institution has the context to pause and verify.

Selling this human-in-the-loop security model is highly effective. It allows the treasury management sales officer to say: "We provide the same high-speed rails as the big banks, but we wrap them in a layer of local oversight that ensures your money only moves when and where it is supposed to."

The Security First Sales Framework

To turn security into a revenue driver, treasury management teams must adopt a structured framework for their sales calls. This framework moves away from scare tactics and toward empowerment.

Step 1: The Risk Assessment Discovery: Instead of starting with a product demo, start with a discovery session focused on the client’s current internal controls. Ask questions such as:

• "Who in your organization has the authority to initiate a payment, and who has the authority to approve it?"
• "If a vendor sends you an email today changing their payment instructions, what is your formal process for verifying that change?"
• "How often do you review the user permissions in your online banking portal to ensure former employees no longer have access?"

By asking these questions, the sales officer is not selling; they are consulting. They are identifying gaps that the client may not even know existed.

Step 2: Positioning the Protection Bundle: Once the gaps are identified, the community bank or credit union should present a protection bundle rather than a list of individual services. This bundle might include:

• Dual Control: Requiring two separate users to authorize any instant payment.
• Positive Pay for ACH and Check: Ensuring that only pre-authorized debits hit the account.
• Out-of-Band Authentication: Requiring a secondary code via a secure app or token.
• Daily Reporting and Alerts: Real-time notifications for any activity over a certain dollar threshold.

When these are sold as a security suite, the value proposition is much higher than when they are sold as individual line-item fees.

Educating the Receiver

A unique aspect of instant payments that is often overlooked in sales is the receiver’s responsibility. In the traditional ACH world, the focus is almost entirely on the sender. However, in a real-time environment, the receiver of the funds also plays a critical role in the security ecosystem.

Community banks and credit unions should educate their commercial clients on the importance of knowing your vendor. If a client receives an instant payment that seems suspicious, they need to know how to handle it without inadvertently participating in a money-laundering or money mule scheme. This educational approach positions the community bank or credit union as a thought leader. By providing webinars, white papers or "fraud coffee talks," your financial institution becomes a true partner in combating fraud and saving business clients’ bottom line.

The Value of the Pause

Consider a hypothetical situation involving a local construction firm. This firm uses instant payments to pay subcontractors on Friday afternoons, ensuring the workers have their funds for the weekend. This is a high-value use case that builds loyalty with the subcontractors.

One Friday, the firm’s office manager receives an urgent email from the primary electrical contractor stating that their bank account has changed and the payment must be sent to a new account immediately. Under the pressure of the deadline, the office manager initiates the FedNow^® payment to the new account.

In a speed-only banking relationship, that money is gone in seconds. However, in a security-first relationship, the community bank or credit union’s treasury management system flags the new routing number as an anomaly for this specific relationship. The institution’s operations team places a brief administrative hold and calls the firm’s CFO. The CFO verifies with the electrical contractor via a known phone number and discovers the email was a spoof.

The community financial institution did more than process a payment. They saved the client $40,000. That client will never leave that community bank or credit union for a lower fee at a national bank. That is the power of security as a sales strategy.

Operationalizing the Strategy by Bridging Sales and Ops

For this strategy to work, there must be total alignment between the treasury management sales team and the operations department. If the sales team promises high-touch security but the operations department is overwhelmed and cannot perform the necessary verifications, the trust factor evaporates.

The Security Service Level Agreement (SLA): Community banks and credit unions should develop internal SLAs that specify when and how security interventions occur. This ensures that the pause for security does not become a permanent stop that frustrates the client. Operations teams should be trained not just on the technical aspects of fraud detection but also on the client experience of a security call.

The Feedback Loop: Sales teams should regularly share the fraud near-misses they hear about in the market with the operations team. Conversely, the operations department should provide the sales team with data on how many fraudulent attempts were blocked in the previous quarter. This data is sales gold. Being able to tell a prospect, "Last quarter, our security protocols protected our clients from $1.2 million in attempted fraudulent transactions," is a powerful closing statement.

The Financial Impact Beyond the Fee Income

While selling security bundles generates non-interest income through service charges, the true financial impact for community banks and credit unions is found in retention and deposit growth.

Commercial deposits are the lifeblood of community financial institutions. In a volatile interest rate environment, these deposits are at risk of moving to higher-yield vehicles or larger institutions. However, sticky relationships are built on trust, not just on the basis points. A client who trusts their bank or credit union to protect their operating account is far less likely to move those deposits elsewhere for a marginal increase in yield.

Furthermore, a security-first reputation attracts high-quality prospects. Professional services firms, medical practices and municipalities (entities that handle significant third-party funds) prioritize security above almost all other banking features. By winning these security-sensitive clients, community banks and credit unions build a more stable and lower-cost deposit base.

Key Takeaways: The Future of Treasury Management

The transition to an always-on economy is inevitable. Instant payments will soon become the standard rather than the exception. For community financial institutions, the path to growth in this new reality is not to compete on the pipes, but to compete on the protection.

By transitioning to a security-as-a-sales-strategy mindset, community banks and credit unions can transform their treasury management departments from back-office support functions into proactive revenue engines. They can move from simply being a payments vendor to a guardian of liquidity.

The revenue is not just in the transaction; it is in the peace of mind provided to the client. In the world of treasury management, speed is a commodity, but trust is a premium.